This one took a while, but it was worth it.
(Click on the title below to play the song.)
By Drew Bunting and Brian Francis Slattery
Utica is a small city in upstate New York that too many people, including myself, have used as the butt end of a joke, the kind you tell because it’s either that or you cry. Upstate New York’s cities can all seem like lost causes, places that saw their best days already. There’s the wreckage of industry at least a generation gone, and the relics of that past all around, in the gorgeous masonry on churches, public buildings, even small apartment buildings, places that nobody has the money to maintain now. I drove around Binghamton and Johnson City, south of Utica, just a little while ago, and went past miles of empty storefronts, windows of plywood. Nobody on the streets. How can these places ever come back? You visit them and can’t help but think that maybe they should do as Youngstown, Ohio is doing, and remake themselves as much smaller places, to do the very brave thing of giving up what they had and working with what they have.
But then you look closer and see the life. In Utica, the same conditions that made so many people leave the place—in the 1990s, Utica lost its three major industrial employers in the space of five years—have also made it a sanctuary for people who come here with nothing, as Utica has opened its doors to wave after wave of refugees. They come from former Yugoslavia, Somalia, Burma, Vietnam, Laos—thirty-one countries, they say now—and many of them are remaking parts of the city that had been given up on. It seems weird at first glance, this roiling diversity in an upstate New York town, until you remember that immigrants—Irish, Italians, Poles—built Utica in the first place. It’s not a seamless process, and there’s still the ruins of its past to contend with. But there’s hope in the idea that people are coming to Utica to start again, as they have before, even if I can’t articulate it very well.
For this title, Drew and I decided to work together more closely than usual. So first I wrote a story that explicitly followed the structure of a song: it had three verses and a bridge. I figured I’d leave the chorus to Drew. Drew liked the story and said he’d get back to me. It took a while, but when he did, I discovered that he’d managed to cram pretty much everything I’d written into his lyrics. I didn’t have anything to add; the story is in the song.
But then there was the question of how to record it, as it was about an accordion player (and an accordion), and neither of us played accordion. Luckily, we knew a phenomenal player, Christina Crowder, who, bless her, was totally game to involve herself with this ridiculous project. But by the time we got to that point, Clifftop—a ten-day music festival in West Virginia—was only a month away, and since we were all going, we had the idea that maybe we could record it there, live, into one mike. And also assemble a roughly twenty-piece band to play and sing it with us. Which we did. And in so doing, made one of the most exciting musical moments I’ve had the privilege to be a part of all year. Thanks to everyone who took part in recording it, from the dear friends to the strangers we pulled in at the last minute to swell the choir. I hope you like it.
—Brian
P.S. Drew here: I want to double up on Brian’s thanks to everyone who pitched in, especially the mighty Joe Bass for his minimalist engineering (“put the mic there”). We know some fantastic musicians, the kind of fantastic where you play them the song once, tell them where to stand, and press record. This is the first take.
P.P.S. from Brian and Drew. For the record: Drew sang lead and played guitar. Christina Crowder played accordion. Ken Bloom played clarinet. Joe Bass and Bryan Thomas both played bass; Bryan used a bow and also hit a tambourine with his foot. Brian played violin, sang in the choir, and clapped his hands. Maggie Neatherlin played violin and sang. Harry Bolick played violin and sang, in his words, “like a tree shredder.” Dan Ruckdeschel, Ben Stowe, Sarah Stowe, Mark Piro, Ian Piro, and Evan Piro all sang and clapped their hands, too, along with Annie, Donald, Steve, Eric, Bill, Breitan, and Kim, whose last names we cannot recall, which we are sorry for, because you all sound beautiful. If you find this, tell us who you are.